Senior Fidelity & Crime Underwriter – NYC Hybrid

Posted yesterday

summit consultingNew York (NY)

Insurance Underwriters Direct Property and Casualty Insurance Carriers

SENIORITY

Senior

Apply

About the role

Great American Insurance Group in New York City is seeking a Senior Underwriter for the Fidelity/Crime division. The role supports market-facing underwriting, pricing, and profitable growth across NYC, Long Island, and Northern New Jersey, with a hybrid NYC office arrangement. The ideal candidate has 3–10+ years in underwriting or business development, plus strong negotiation and communication skills, and a willingness to travel locally. Competitive benefits and salary are offered.

Before you apply

Applying takes about a minute. These four things decide how fast it moves after that.

Your profile is current

It's what we read first. Occupations, seniority and locations matter more than a long history.

Two examples you can talk through

Not a portfolio — just two pieces of work where you can explain the decisions and what you'd change.

A number in mind

What you're on now and what would make you move. We negotiate better when we know both.

Your notice period

Employers plan around it, and it's the question that stalls offers most often.

Once you apply, someone reads it and calls you before anything reaches the employer — usually within two working days.