Agency Success Manager
renegade insuranceMiami (FL)
About the role
We’re looking for an experienced Agency Success Manager to partner with independent insurance agency owners and help them build stronger, more productive, and more profitable businesses. This is a senior, hands-on role for someone who combines Personal Lines insurance expertise, strong sales coaching skills, and disciplined execution.
What you’ll do:
Serve as a strategic advisor and performance coach to agency owners Develop and execute agency growth plans tied to clear production goals and KPIsCoach owners and producers on sales strategy, pipeline management, conversion, cross-selling, and account rounding Use performance data to identify gaps, diagnose challenges, and drive corrective action Provide guidance on Personal Lines carriers, appetite, products, underwriting requirements, and placement strategy Establish a consistent operating cadence with agencies, including performance reviews, action plans, and follow-through Hold agency owners accountable to commitments and growth objectives Partner with carrier, sales, training, and operations teams to remove barriers to agency growth Identify best practices across high-performing agencies and help scale them across the network
What we’re looking for:
3-5 years of experience in Personal Lines insurance, preferably within the independent agency channel Strong knowledge of Personal Lines P&C insurance, including products, coverage, quoting, underwriting, and carrier requirements. Understanding of carrier relationships, appetite, underwriting, and agency operations Proven experience coaching agency owners, producers, or sales teams Strong commercial mindset with the ability to translate data into actionable growth strategies Highly structured, disciplined, and accountable Comfortable having direct conversations around performance and expectations Strong executive communication and relationship-management skillsA track record of driving measurable sales or agency growth Ideal background: Agency leadership, carrier territory management, agency development, sales leadership, or a similar role supporting the growth and performance of independent insurance agencies. We’re looking for someone who can walk into a conversation with an agency owner, quickly understand the business, identify what is holding it back, and build a clear plan to move it forward. Location & Work Arrangement This position is based in Miami, Florida and requires working from the office. Candidates should be comfortable working in an on-site environment and collaborating closely with agency teams.
Compensation & Benefits
Compensation:
Competitive salary based on experience and qualifications, plus applicable performance incentives.
Benefits include:
Medical, dental, and vision insurance Paid time off 401(k)Professional development and training Employee growth opportunities
Before you apply
Applying takes about a minute. These four things decide how fast it moves after that.
Your profile is current
It's what we read first. Occupations, seniority and locations matter more than a long history.
Two examples you can talk through
Not a portfolio — just two pieces of work where you can explain the decisions and what you'd change.
A number in mind
What you're on now and what would make you move. We negotiate better when we know both.
Your notice period
Employers plan around it, and it's the question that stalls offers most often.
Once you apply, someone reads it and calls you before anything reaches the employer — usually within two working days.
More like this